The cultural aspirations, attitudes and behaviour of both parents and children play an important part in academic attainment. Research has shown, the more parents are engaged in the education of their children, the more likely their children are to succeed in the education system (Harris, 2007). School improvement and school effectiveness research consistently shows that parental engagement is one of the key factors in securing higher student achievement (Goodal et al, 2010). This article will examine the effect of parental aspirations on education in both China and England.
It is argued parents in China have greater educational expectations for their children than do parents in the England (Jin et al, 2014). Researchers have attributed the high academic achievement of students in China to their parents' high expectations and willing-ness to put in time and effort for their children's education (Schneider & Lee, 1990; Stevenson & Lee, 1990). Chinese parents place more emphasis on effort and English parents have a more fatalistic approach and place more emphasis on ability and IQ. Chinese parents often view their child’s difficulty with the educational material as directly related to a lack of effort by their child. In contrast, English parents are more likely to rationalise their children’s difficulty as a deficiency in the ability of the child, the teacher, or even the school (Li, 2003).
Issues surrounding parental aspirations in England appear to be more closely related to social class; the gap between rich and poor children is already large at the age of three, but continues to widen in the primary and early secondary years. One of the biggest distinctions between poorer and richer families is the extent to which parents aspire towards higher education, and how much they believe their own actions can make a really big difference in the lives of their children (Goodman, 2010). A report by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (2010) found that only 37 per cent of the poorest mothers hoped their nine-year-old would go to university compared with 81 per cent of the richest mothers. However, in China education has been highly valued since classical time, regardless of economic or social position.
Parents in China play a strong role in their children's education through encouraging high aspirations and promoting academic achievement (Kao, 1995; Zhou, 2000). Traditional Chinese philosophy emphasises education above other values. This cultural value on learning continues to be important in Chinese society today; a high standard of education is associated with higher social status and the vast majority of parents have high expectations for the educational achievements of their children. This, together with the introduction of the one child policy, leads to parents making great sacrifices in order to ensure that their children receives the best possible education. Parents and entire families place their hopes in the educational success of their single offspring (Deodhar, 2012). However this pressure to do well can have a negative effect on young peoples mental health and increasingly England too.
Although it is clear to see there is a distinct correlation between parental aspirations and academic attainment in both England and China, in England there is a much larger gap between disadvantaged children and their peers. This difference is not seen in China possibly due to the suggestion of there being no social class.
By Zoe Westgarth
England and China class sizes compared
In this article I will make comparisons between the impact of smaller class sizes on student achievement in England and China.
Smaller classes are favoured by parents and teachers. England and China are recognised as having large classroom sizes. The issue with small class sizes is that money spent on smaller classes can not be spent on better teacher salaries, and better opportunities for the professional development of teachers.
According to the The annual report on education in richer nations by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development the average class size twenty-one. However the average class size in the UK state sector is twenty-six which is marginally higher than the average. The cause of the increase in classroom sizes are due to pressure being placed on schools by rising birth rates and the effects of immigration, and experts have claimed that large classes can reduce the quality of children's education.
China similarly have large classroom sizes with an average of thirty-eight pupils. However in China class size depends on the region. In a national minority area the average class size is twenty-four, but in towns forty it is forty. Cultural factors also affect the classroom sizes throughout the year, as in some rural areas teachers and pupils are permitted to help family agricultural work for planting or harvesting, so there are seasonal variations in class sizes.
The quality of additional teachers that are brought into schools can determine whether or not having a large class size will be an issue. Chinese teachers are known to be well trained, and highly qualified and therefore see little correlation between class size and learning outcomes. Benbow, Mizrachi, Oliver & Said-Moshiro (2007) described that large class size is an inevitable feature of the developing countries.
Evidence suggests that class sizes do in fact contribute to the quality of learning in England, as one can not separate out teacher quality from the social context. Larger classes in most regions of the UK would have a negative effect because of student behaviour, which is not a problem they face in the high-performing countries like China. Achievement and working conditions are also negative effects of having large classes in England, and so it is evident that smaller classes produce higher achievement levels. (OECD 2014). The predicament however is that smaller class sizes mean that it is necessary to bring in more teachers to raise more classes which is costly.
To conclude research indicates that increasing class sizes have a detrimental effect on student behaviour and in hindsight, reduce the opportunities for schools to provide the level and quality of teaching that is needed to enhance student learning and achievement. Cramped conditions may adversely affect children’s behavior and academic performance (Maxwell 2003; Evans, Saegert and Harris 2001). Research evidence suggests that reduced class size in the early years of primary education is positively associated with higher academic attainment and a better attendance record (Finn et al. 2001). However smaller class sizes are costly as highly trained teachers are required. As previously mentioned it is inevitable to have larger class sizes in China as it is a developing country. However teacher quality in China is at a high level, and therefore class size may not be as detrimental towards students many believe them to be.
Jadene Richards
Comparisons of Education in China and England
In England if a student does not perform well in an exam it will not affect their life drastically. Instead the exams result is used to motivate children to achieve a better results next time. However, in China overall performance in the Goakoa exam determines student’s ability, dreams and aspirations. Therefore students are in great pressure to perform well and pass, there is no other option.
Analysing further, the Goakoa exam determines intellectual ability and achievement, based on this students are given a place at college. Unfortunately, for many Chinese students the pressure is too great to handle as a result, for those students who believe they performed poorly did not wait to see their results. A study revealed that “500 students commit suicide each year under academic pressure brought by the examination-based education system”. (Ncess.org, 2014). Analyzing this key point it is evident that education, exam and grading has a huge impact on the lives of Chinese students.
Moreover, a key aspect highlighted throughout the video is parental aspirations. With the introduction of the one child Policy (1979) Parents in China have high expectations of their single offspring. Students feel there is immense pressure from their parents. Critically analyzing further, parental aspiration can positively influence student ability as family can be a drive and motivation in a student’s education. However, it can negatively influence the education as parental pressure may be too much therefore, students may seek to commit suicide to save themselves and their families from shame.
To conclude, based on my primary research it is evident China’s educational system is based upon exams that solely determine student ability. But I feel this is unfair as some students may be kinesthetic learners and perform well in practicals or presentations. Therefore I feel China’s education system can improve if they take a child centred approach, which means they listen and meet the child’s needs.
By Sarah Khan
Throughout this academic writing piece it is my intention to critical analyse the video “In China, 1 Exam is Everything”. (YouTube, 2014). This video will primarily focus on the National College Entrance Exams (Goakoa) and the academic pressure it has on students. To do this I will be comparing and contrasting two articles. The first article (Universityworldnews.com, 2014) focuses on the academic pressure Goakoa can have on students and their education. The second article (Harris, 2007) highlights the effect of parental aspirations on students in China.
“In China, 1 Exam is Everything”, shows the academic pressure Chinese students endure from the Goakoa. China remains a highly competitive education system and aims to improve its economic growth but, for many Chinese student education is a route to a better future. Therefore it is vital to be educated, as education leads to employment from which money is earned as a result, individuals can purchase goods in life like cars and houses.
The video highlights the importance of the Goakoa exam, students must pass the Goakoa exam in order to ensure their place at a college. The Goakoa pays no attention to extra-curricular work, only a score on a single test, it places students on a career path they will follow for the rest their life. I feel the exam result can send a child to the factory floor or to the top levels of China’s booming economy.
I'm a title. Click here to edit me
I'm a paragraph. Click here to add your own text and edit me. It’s easy. Just click “Edit Text” or double click me to add your own content and make changes to the font. Feel free to drag and drop me anywhere you like on your page. I’m a great place for you to tell a story and let your users know a little more about you.
This is a great space to write long text about your company and your services. You can use this space to go into a little more detail about your company. Talk about your team and what services you provide. Tell your visitors the story of how you came up with the idea for your business and what makes you different from your competitors. Make your company stand out and show your visitors who you are.
At Wix we’re passionate about making templates that allow you to build fabulous websites and it’s all thanks to the support and feedback from users like you! Keep up to date with New Releases and what’s Coming Soon in Wixellaneous in Support. Feel free to tell us what you think and give us feedback in the Wix Forum. If you’d like to benefit from a professional designer’s touch, head to the Wix Arena and connect with one of our Wix Pro designers. Or if you need more help you can simply type your questions into the Support Forum and get instant answers. To keep up to date with everything Wix, including tips and things we think are cool, just head to the Wix Blog!